Navigating the Compliance Maze: A Guide for Mission-Driven Organizations

You just launched a beautiful new website after months of work. It’s engaging, tells your story, and the board of directors loves it. Then you receive a formal letter. Your site violates accessibility standards, and you’re facing legal action. Suddenly, your digital cornerstone becomes a liability.

Website compliance isn’t just a technical checkbox—it’s about protecting both your organization and those you serve. Understanding this is your first step in navigating these waters safely, and proper evaluation is how you’ll chart your course.

The Changing Stakes of Website Compliance

The simple days of having a website that shows off your logo and contact information are long gone. Today, your website is much more than a glorified digital brochure. It’s where people donate, register for events, access services, and share sensitive information. As websites have evolved from static pages to dynamic platforms, compliance requirements have grown accordingly.

And the stakes have never been higher. ADA-related website lawsuits continue to be filed each year, with settlements often reaching tens of thousands of dollars. What’s more sobering, 77% of ADA lawsuits in 2023 targeted companies with under $25 million in revenue, indicating that small businesses are particularly at risk. But beyond financial penalties, non-compliance damages your reputation and excludes the very people you’re trying to serve.

What’s changed with website compliance?

• Digital compliance now spans multiple interconnected areas:
• Legal standards have expanded beyond accessibility to include data privacy and security
• Enforcement has become more rigorous, with both regulatory actions by the Department of Justice and private lawsuits

Public expectations have evolved, with 73% of users abandoning sites with poor accessibility. People assume you’ll protect their data and provide equal access
As your organization grows, so do your compliance obligations. What works for a small startup might not for an established organization serving thousands. That’s why an ongoing commitment to regular evaluation and monitoring matters.

Core Types of Website Compliance

Any time legal jargon is involved, we run the risk of misunderstanding what big words mean. But you don’t need a law degree to understand the core types of website compliance. Let’s break it down into three main categories. Think of these as the foundation of a healthy website.

Digital Accessibility

What it means in plain English: Making your website usable by everyone, including people with disabilities. This ensures that someone who’s blind can navigate your site with a screen reader, or someone who can’t use a mouse can still fill out your forms.

Key standards to know:

• WCAG 2.1 (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines): The gold standard for accessibility. It’s organized into three levels (A, AA, AAA), with most organizations aiming for AA compliance.
• ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act): While not specifically mentioning websites, courts have consistently interpreted this law to include digital spaces as “places of public accommodation.”
• Section 508: Requirements that federal agencies and their contractors must meet. If you work with government entities, this likely applies to you.

Pro tip: Build accessibility into your design process from the ground up rather than trying to retrofit it later. When accessibility is baked into your initial planning, it becomes part of your site’s DNA rather than a bolt-on feature.

Data Privacy and Protection

What it means in plain English: Being transparent about what information you collect from visitors and how you use it. It’s about respecting people’s right to know what happens with their personal details.

Common regulations:

• GDPR (Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation): Gives people control over their personal data. Even if you’re U.S.-based, this applies if you have European visitors or handle data of EU residents.
• CCPA/CPRA (California Consumer Privacy Act): California’s privacy law that gives residents the right to know what data is collected and to opt out of having their information sold.
• Cookie consent: Those pop-ups asking permission to track you aren’t just annoying. They’re legally required in many jurisdictions.
• Privacy policies: The document explaining how you handle user information is a legal requirement in most cases.

Security Compliance

What it means in plain English: Protecting your website and user data from hackers and breaches. It’s the digital equivalent of locking your doors and installing an alarm system.

Key requirements:

• SSL/HTTPS: The padlock in your browser that indicates encrypted connections. Search engines now penalize sites without this protection.
• PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard): Rules for safely handling credit card information. If you accept online payments, this applies to you.
• Password and authentication standards: How you verify users’ identities and protect accounts.
• Breach notification requirements: What you’re legally required to do if someone does manage to access sensitive data.

Privacy requirements and security threats evolve constantly, which, again, is why ongoing monitoring is essential. What’s compliant today might not be tomorrow as new laws, interpretations, and vulnerabilities emerge. Understanding these compliance areas builds trust with your audience and ensures your digital presence truly serves everyone.

Industry-Specific Considerations

Different industries face unique compliance challenges beyond the basics. Here’s what you should know about requirements specific to your field:

Non-profits & Associations

Your donors and members trust you with both their money and their information. Pay special attention to:

• Donor data protection: Proper handling of financial information and giving history requires specific security measures.
• Transparency requirements: Many states have specific rules about how non-profits must disclose financial information online.
• Member information: Member directories and community features need careful privacy controls.
• Fundraising regulations: Digital fundraising campaigns may trigger specific compliance requirements depending on your location and reach.

For mission-driven organizations, inclusive design isn’t just a legal requirement—it’s an extension of your values. Your digital presence should be as welcoming and accessible as your physical one.

Healthcare & Education

Organizations working with vulnerable populations face some of the strictest compliance requirements:

• HIPAA essentials: If you handle any health information, you need robust safeguards to protect patient privacy.
• FERPA requirements: Educational institutions must carefully manage student records and information sharing.
• Telehealth considerations: Remote service delivery brings additional compliance layers beyond standard healthcare rules.
• Accessibility imperatives: These sectors face particularly high standards for making content accessible to all users.

Regular compliance testing is especially important here, as regulations change frequently and penalties can be severe.

Real Estate & Professional Services

When your website facilitates significant financial or legal decisions, compliance matters even more:

• Fair Housing Act: Real estate websites must avoid discrimination in property listings and search functionality.
• Licensing disclosures: Professional credentials and licensing information must be properly displayed.
• Client confidentiality: Secure client portals and document sharing must meet specific standards.
• Financial information protection: Special requirements apply when handling financial data.

Building these protections from the ground up ensures they’re seamlessly integrated rather than awkwardly attached.

Retail & Technology

E-commerce and tech platforms face evolving compliance challenges:

• E-commerce regulations: Clear return policies, pricing accuracy, and shipping information are legally required.
• Subscription management: Auto-renewals and recurring billing have specific disclosure requirements.
• Data handling fundamentals: Tech companies face heightened scrutiny regarding how user data flows through systems.
• International considerations: Selling across borders triggers compliance with multiple jurisdictions.

The key is recognizing which regulations apply to your specific situation rather than trying to implement everything at once.

When to Seek Expert Compliance Support

While understanding compliance basics is valuable, certain situations signal it’s time to bring in professional help:

• You’re connecting with a large audience: What works for 100 visitors a month won’t cut it for 10,000
• Your website handles sensitive information: Financial data, health records, or children’s information require specialized protections
• You’re expanding into new regions: Different states and countries have different requirements
• You’ve received a compliance complaint: If you’ve been notified of an issue, professional guidance can prevent escalation
• You’re undergoing a website redesign: It’s much easier (and cheaper) to build compliance in from the beginning than retrofit it later

If you recognize these warning signs, expert guidance can save you time, money, and reputation in the long run.

The limitations of DIY compliance tools

Let’s face it: website compliance is not a weekend DIY project. Those automated compliance checkers and plugins have their place, but they often catch only the most obvious issues. They might tell you about missing alt text on images but miss complex navigation problems that make your site unusable for keyboard-only users.

DIY tools typically can’t understand context or make judgment calls about what’s truly accessible to people with different abilities. They might throw up false flags, or worse, fail to prioritize issues by severity. They treat minor cosmetic concerns with the same urgency as deal-breaking barriers that prevent entire groups of people from using your site.

Most importantly, one-time fixes rarely solve compliance challenges for the long term. The digital landscape evolves constantly, with new devices, browsers, and assistive technologies emerging regularly. Proper compliance requires ongoing monitoring, testing with real users, and regular updates to stay ahead of changing requirements.

Conclusion

Compliance isn’t just about checking boxes or avoiding penalties. It’s a fundamental part of your website’s wellness. Like a regular health checkup, addressing compliance proactively protects your organization’s mission and expands your reach. By understanding these requirements, you’ve taken the first step toward a digital presence that truly serves everyone.

Is your website fully compliant?

A comprehensive website wellness check can identify potential issues before they become problems.

Talk to our team today